Calibration and Verification of Flexible Rice Straw Model by Discrete Element Method

XIA Junfang, ZHANG Peng, YUAN Hongwen, DU Jun, ZHENG Kan, LI Yufei

Abstract

Rice straw in the fields of the middle and lower reaches of the Yangtze River exhibits high stubble retention and a substantial straw volume. The interaction between straw and tools are complicated and have a significant impact on the performance of straw incorporation implement. The lack of accurate rice straw model by discrete element method (DEM) limits the analysis of the interaction between straw and tools during the design and optimization of key components of straw incorporation implement. A flexible rice straw model was established by the particle replacement method based on the Hertz-Mindlin with Bonding contact model in DEM. Calibration of the discrete element model and multi-condition experimental verification were conducted. The friction coefficients of rice straw were determined through physical experiments, and the maximum load was measured in the straw bending test as the calibration index. The Plackett-Burman experiment and the steepest ascent experiment were used to select significant factors and their optimal value ranges for the flexible model, and the optimal parameter combinations for significant factors of the straw bonding model were determined by Central-Composite tests. The result was the normal contact stiffness was 3.040×1010 N/m3, and the tangential contact stiffness was 2.296×1010 N/m3. The relative error between the maximum load obtained from the simulation with the calibrated parameters and the actual maximum load with the experiment was 1.82%. It indicated the effectiveness of the calibration method. To verify the effectiveness of the above calibration method under different working conditions, the bending test of blades and the rotating cutting test of the rotary blade were conducted. The relative error between the maximum load obtained with the simulation and experiment in the bending test of blades was not more than 4.55%, while the relative error of the maximum torque between the simulation and experiment in the rotating cutting test of the rotary blade was not more than 7.95%. It indicated that the flexible rice straw model by DEM calibrated using the bending test was accurate and effective in simulating straw bending test and rotating cutting of the rotary blade processes and applicable to simulation analysis under the rotary tillage operating conditions. The research provided an effective model and method to analysis of the interaction between straw and tools for the optimization design of key components of straw incorporation implement.

 

Keywords:rice straw, discrete element, parameters calibration, cutting, rotary tillage

 

Download Full Text:

PDF


References


ZHU Yinghao,XIA Junfang,ZENG Rong,et al. Prediction model of rotary tillage power consumption in paddy stubble field based on discrete element method [J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery, 2020,51 (10) :42 - 50. (in Chinese)

YANG Qinglu,CHEN Guibin,XIE Lijuan,et al. Design and experiment of telescopic finger stalk of maize straw burying machine [J ]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery ,2020 ,51 (12) :35 -43. (in Chinese)

QI Zhijuan ,S()NG Fang,ZHANG Zhongxue,et al. Effects of different conservation tillage methods on soil hydrothermal conditions as well as maize yield in cold black soil region [J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery, 2022 , 53( 12) :380 -389. (in Chinese)

GETAHUN G T,KATTERER T,MUNKHOLM L J,et al. Short-term effects of loosening and incorporation of straw slurry into the upper subsoil on soil physical properties and crop yield | J ]. Soil and Tillage Research ,2018 ,184 :62 -67.

YANG H,XL M,KOIDE R T,et al. Effects of ditchburied straw return on water percolation, nitrogen leaching and crop yields in a rice-wheat rotation system [J]. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture ,2016 ,96 (4) ; 1141 - 1149.

XUE L,YU Y,YANG L. Maintaining yields and reducing nitrogen loss in rice — wheat rotation system in Taihu Lake region with proper fertilizer management [ J ] . Environmental Research Letters,2014 ,9( 1 1 ) ; 1 15010.

WANG Jinfeng,YANG Dongze,W ANG Zhentao,et al. Design and experiment of rice straw biaxial deep-buried returning machine [J] . Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery ,2023 ,54( 4) ;21 -30. (in Chinese)

ZIIOU IIua,LI Dong, LIU Zhengyuan,et al. Simulation and experiment of spatial distribution effect after straw incorporation into soil by rotary burial[ J ]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery ,2019 ,50( 9) :69 -77. (in Chinese)

HE Ruiyin.DUAN Qingfei,CHEN Xinxin.et al. DEM analysis of spatial distribution quality of rotary tillage straw returning [ J ]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery ,2022 ,53 (6) :44 -53. (in Chinese)

YU Qingxu.LIU Yan,CHEN Xiaobing,et al. Calibration and experiment of simulation parameters for Panax notoginseng seeds based on DEM [J ]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery,2020,51 (2) ;123 - 132. ( in Chinese)

MA Yanhua,SONG Chundong, XU AN Chuanzhong, et al. Parameters calibration of discrete element model for alfalfa straw compressing simulation [J]. Transactions of the CSAE,2020,36( 1 1 ) ;22 -30. (in Chinese)

ZHANG Rui,HAN Dianlei,JI Qiaoli,et al. Calibration methods of sandy soil parameters in simulation of discrete element method [J] .Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery ,2017 ,48 ( 3 ) :49 -56. (in Chinese)

SHI Y,XIN S,WANG X,et al. Numerical simulation and field tests of minimuin-tillage planter with straw smashing and strip laying based on EDEM software [ J ]. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture,2019 ,166 :105021.

FANG Huimin,JI Changying, AHMED Ali Tagar,et al. Simulation analysis of straw movement in straw - soil - rotary blade system [ J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery ,2016 ,47 ( 1 ) :60 -67. ( in Chinese)

LIU Y,LI Y,ZHANG T,et al. Effect of concentric and non-concentric threshing gaps on damage of rice straw during threshing for combine harvester [ J ]. Biosystems Engineering,2022,219 ; 1 - 10.

WANG Y, ZHANG Y, YANG Y,et al. Discrete element modelling of citrus fruit stalks and its verification [ J J. Biosystems Engineering,2020,200 :400 - 414.

LENAERTS B,TIJSKENS E, BAERDEMAEKER J,et al. Simulation of graine straw separation by discrete element modeling with bendable straw particles[ J]. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture,2012 ,101 :24 -33.

ZHU Huibin,QIAN Cheng, BAI Lizhen,et al. Optimization of discrete element model of corn stalk based on Plackett — Burman design and response surface methodology [ J] .Journal of China Agricultural University ,2021 ,26( 12) : 221 -231. (in Chinese)

SHI Ruijie, DAI Fei, ZHAO Wuyun, et al. Establishment of discrete element flexible model and verification of contact parameters of flax stem [ J ]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery, 2022,53 ( 10) : 146 - 155. ( in Chinese)

JIAO Jun,ZHANG Guozhong,DU Jun,et al. Discrete element simulation of bending failure of main lotus root[ J]. Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University,2021 ,40(5) :217 -225. (in Chinese)


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.